Share Your Feedback

Considering your experience with Sharlife so far, how likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague?
Not at all likely Extremely likely
(Optional)

iRCPS: Shariah-Compliant Shares or Investment Trap? Understand the Risks & Reality

iRCPS: Shariah-Compliant Shares or Investment Trap? Understand the Risks & Reality

 

Recently, a controversy emerged involving a prominent Islamic figure who was linked to a Shariah-compliant investment scheme based on iRCPS. The investment offering reportedly resulted in significant losses for many investors. This scheme introduced an investment instrument known as Islamic Redeemable Convertible Preference Shares (iRCPS). The question remains: is it truly Shariah-compliant, or merely a trap disguised with Islamic terminology?

What is Redeemable Convertible Preference Shares (iRCPS)?

Redeemable Convertible Preference Shares (iRCPS), also known as Islamic Redeemable Preference Shares (RPS-i), refer to the same product. Both are hybrid instruments combining two main features — equity and debt — structured in accordance with Shariah principles, particularly the prohibition of riba (interest), risk-sharing, and the Shariah-compliant use of funds.

iRCPS is a type of preference share that represents a form of ownership in a company. In Malaysia, iRCPS is regulated under the Companies Act 2016, which allows companies with share capital to issue preference shares — including iRCPS — as long as it is provided for in the company’s constitution.

Investors who purchase iRCPS are entitled to receive dividends at a predetermined rate set during the contract issuance, depending on the company’s profitability. One of the advantages of iRCPS holders is that they receive dividend payments before ordinary shareholders.

However, iRCPS is also a redeemable security, meaning the issuing company has the option to buy back the shares from holders at a predetermined price. Therefore, the iRCPS investment scheme is essentially a hybrid investment between equity and debt.

Key Features of Redeemable Convertible Preference Shares (iRCPS)

  1. Dividends:

iRCPS holders receive dividends at a predetermined rate and are prioritized over ordinary shareholders. Dividends are distributed based on the company's profits and not fixed interest, in line with Shariah principles that emphasize risk and return sharing between the company and investors.

  1. Redeemable:

The issuing company has the right to buy back the iRCPS at an agreed price after a specified period. This provides flexibility in the company’s capital management.

  1. Convertible:

iRCPS holders have the option to convert these shares into ordinary shares at a set conversion rate, offering potential gains from future appreciation in the value of ordinary shares.

  1. Shariah Principles 

  •  Emphasizes risk-sharing between iRCPS holders and the company.

  • Dividends are distributed only when the company makes a profit.

  • In the event of losses, iRCPS holders may not receive dividends.

  • There must be no elements of gharar (uncertainty) or maysir (gambling) in the redemption and conversion structure.

Conversion Structure

Conversion of iRCPS to ordinary shares can occur in two ways:

  • Fixed to Variable: The original investment is converted based on the market value of ordinary shares at the time of conversion. This provides potential market-based returns and indirect capital protection.

  • Fixed to Fixed: The number of ordinary shares to be received is predetermined, but their market value may vary at the time of conversion. This could result in either capital gains or losses.

Use of Funds

Funds raised through the issuance of iRCPS must be used for Shariah-compliant purposes, such as financing productive assets. The funds cannot be used for prohibited activities such as alcohol production, gambling, or other non-compliant businesses.

Investment Risks in iRCPS

Although iRCPS offers attractive features and is structured in line with Shariah principles, it also involves specific risks that must be carefully managed, including:

  • Uncertainty in the company’s profitability.

  • Unpredictable market value when converted to ordinary shares.

  • Risk of non-redemption if the company lacks financial capability.

Convertible Risk

The convertibility feature allows iRCPS holders to convert their preference shares into ordinary shares, often at a favorable rate. However, it also poses a risk of capital loss if the company’s financial performance declines. This is because the market value of ordinary shares may fall, reducing the value of the iRCPS upon conversion.

Redemption Risk

iRCPS gives the issuing company the right to redeem the shares at an agreed price and date. If the company faces liquidity issues, it may delay or fail to redeem the shares, leaving investors with limited recourse.

All redemptions must comply with Section 72 of the Companies Act 2016, which states that redemption can only be made using:

  • Distributable profits,

  • Proceeds from the issuance of new shares, or

  • The company’s capital, subject to passing the solvency test.

Redemption is only valid if the company remains solvent and able to meet all financial obligations after the redemption.

Priority Risk in Liquidation

In the event of company liquidation, iRCPS holders have a higher payment priority than ordinary shareholders. However, their claims come after those of:

  • Secured creditors,

  • Unsecured creditors,

  • The Inland Revenue Board of Malaysia (LHDN),

  • Unpaid employees, and others.

This is governed by the legal concept of liquidation preference, a protection mechanism for investors to recover their original capital if the company becomes insolvent.

If there are surplus assets or profits after all debts are settled, iRCPS investors with participation rights are entitled to share in the remaining balance. Without such rights, they will only receive payment based on the liquidation preference terms.

Therefore, the terms and conditions outlined in the company’s constitution are critical, as they can carry different implications in various scenarios and may give rise to complex legal and technical issues in the future.

Do iRCPS Issuer Companies Require a License from the Securities Commission (SC)?

Companies intending to issue iRCPS do not require a special license from the Securities Commission (SC), but they are still subject to certain disclosure and approval requirements, depending on the method of issuance. The two common methods of iRCPS offerings are:

1. Public Offering:

  • Applications must be submitted to the SC under the Guidelines on Offering of Islamic Securities

  • The SC will review documents, including the prospectus, and grant approval or issue a notification of acceptance.

  • May require a credit rating and Shariah compliance verification.

2. Private Placement:

  • Still subject to Section 212 of the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007 (CMSA).

  • Issuers must notify the SC via a notice and comply with the Guidelines on Unlisted Capital Market Products under the Lodge and Launch Framework (LOLA).

  • In this case, the company only needs to "lodge" documents — formal approval is not required, but the SC is officially informed.

Are iRCPS Investor Shares Held by Nominees and SPVs?

Under the Companies Act 2016, a private limited company (Sdn. Bhd.) is limited to a maximum of 50 shareholders. This is different from a public company (Berhad) which has no such shareholder limit.

Therefore, in equity crowdfunding (ECF) investments, the ECF platform typically establishes a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) to act as a nominee holding shares on behalf of all retail investors. The main purpose of the SPV is to keep the number of shareholders in the issuing company within legal limits while allowing for broad investor participation.

The use of an SPV also simplifies administrative processes and decision-making. If a company needs to obtain resolutions from numerous small investors, the process can be complex and time-consuming. With an SPV in place, only one entity (the SPV) interacts with the issuing company, streamlining and accelerating the decision-making process.

To protect investor rights, a nominee agreement or trust deed is signed between the SPV and the investors. This document clearly states that the SPV is merely a trustee and does not have actual ownership of the shares. In the case of dividend distribution or share sales, the SPV is responsible for distributing proceeds to the actual investors according to their respective stakes.

How Can a Ponzi Scheme Occur Through iRCPS?

Although iRCPS is a legitimate investment instrument, it can be misused by irresponsible parties to run Ponzi schemes. Below are characteristics of fraudulent iRCPS offerings:

  • Promises of unreasonably high or fixed returns.

  • No real business operations by the issuing company.

  • Continuous and unlimited issuance of iRCPS without solid justification.

  • Lack of valid or transparent financial disclosures to investors.

  • No registration or regulatory compliance with the Securities Commission (SC) or frameworks such as LOLA.

In such schemes, dividends paid to early investors usually come from the funds of new investors — not from actual business profits. This tactic creates an illusion of stable returns to lure more investors.

Therefore, investors must exercise caution and avoid being enticed by high-return promises. Always ensure the issuing company is registered with the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) and complies with all regulatory requirements. If the company is not registered, investors will not have legal protection, and the risk of total capital loss is extremely high.

Is iRCPS a Suitable Investment?

iRCPS (Islamic Redeemable Convertible Preference Shares) is generally not a suitable investment for those with limited capital. Although some may be offered publicly, the price per share is typically high. For private placements, only certain qualified investors are eligible to participate—such as financial institutions, takaful operators, high-net-worth individuals (with a net worth exceeding RM3 million), and directors of the issuing company. This is in line with the Guidelines on Unlisted Capital Market Products issued by the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC).

Investing in iRCPS also carries a relatively high level of risk, especially when it involves private companies that are not publicly listed. Even if the company does not incur losses, iRCPS can become a financial trap due to its illiquid nature, as there is usually no active secondary market for reselling these shares.

For investors considering investing through Equity Crowdfunding (ECF), it is important to understand the difference between equity-based investments and debt-based instruments. Furthermore, the “redeemable” feature in iRCPS does not guarantee capital return, as it is not a fixed deposit instrument protected by the Malaysia Deposit Insurance Corporation (PIDM).

Understanding every term in the investment agreement is also crucial. Failing to read and comprehend the contract may expose investors to hidden risks, especially if the issuer inserts clauses that are biased in their favor.

Conclusion

Investment in iRCPS is fundamentally contractual in nature, even though it may offer rights to receive dividends. However, it does not confer full ownership rights like ordinary shares. More importantly, iRCPS is only suitable for sophisticated investors, particularly in private placement offerings.

For inexperienced investors, be sure to thoroughly evaluate every investment detail and fully understand the risks involved. As Warren Buffet once said:

“Don’t invest in something you don’t understand.”

No one is forcing you to make an investment decision. Seek advice from a licensed financial advisor or investment expert if you're uncertain. iRCPS is not for everyone. While it is structured to comply with Shariah principles, its implementation can still be manipulated if regulatory oversight is weak.

Read every investment document carefully. Ask questions. If in doubt—walk away.

 

References:

https://theedgemalaysia.com/article/know-redeemable-convertible-preference-shares-devil-details

https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7256489334910943232/

https://www.ibusinesscap.com.my/islamic-redeemable-preference-shares/

https://www.sc.com.my/api/documentms/download.ashx?id=5bded761-bf84-44cc-b1ea-19a61dbe06ff